Uganda’s electoral history demonstrates that declaring a winner does not necessarily conclude an election. In a constitutional democracy, legitimacy depends not only on the announcement of results but also on the integrity of the processes through which votes are counted, verified and challenged.
The High Court judgment delivered at Mubende on 13 November 2026 in Tumwesigye Fred v Mubangizi Dedan and Others, Election Petition No. 03 of 2026, brings this principle into focus. The court set aside Mubangizi Dedan’s gazetted election as Member of Parliament for Buweekula South after finding that the judicial recount that produced his victory could not be sufficiently relied upon.
Significantly, the court did not declare Tumwesigye Fred directly elected. Instead, it ordered a fresh election. The distinction matters: invalidating an unreliable result does not automatically establish another candidate’s entitlement to the seat. Where the evidence cannot establish a credible final tally, the electorate must have an opportunity to decide again.
Buweekula South must be distinguished from the former Buweekula County. The present constituency was carved out of the larger county ahead of the 2021 general elections, reportedly comprising Kayebe, Kalonga and Kitenga sub-counties. Its creation sought to improve representation and access to public services.
The January 2021 election was therefore the first parliamentary general election for Buweekula South. William Museveni, an independent candidate, was declared winner with 8,075 votes against Tumwesigye’s 7,479, a margin of 596 votes.
Tumwesigye challenged the result, citing alleged electoral irregularities. On 22 September 2021, the High Court at Mubende, presided over by Justice Eva K. Luswata, nullified the election and ordered a fresh poll. However, on 8 June 2022, the Court of Appeal, by a majority of two justices to one, reversed that decision, dismissed the petition and upheld Museveni’s election. Justices Elizabeth Musoke and Monica Mugenyi formed the majority, while Justice Irene Mulyagonja dissented. Consequently, the 2021 court-ordered by-election never took place. The appellate decision restored the original election outcome.
The 2026 general election produced another contest, according to the figures contained in the supplied judgment summary, the initial declaration placed Tumwesigye, contesting as an independent, first with 8,804 votes. Mubangizi Dedan of the NRM followed with 7,998, while Sempiira Edward of NUP received 1,915. Tumwesigye’s initial winning margin was 806 votes.
A judicial recount conducted on 27–28 January 2026 changed the outcome. Mubangizi received 7,908 votes, Tumwesigye 7,504 and Sempiira 1,879. Mubangizi was subsequently declared elected and gazetted on 4 March. However, the combined candidate totals fell from 18,717 in the initial declaration to 17,291 after the recount a reduction of 1,426 votes. This difference alone does not prove wrongdoing, but it raises legitimate questions about the handling, preservation and verification of electoral materials.
In its 13 November ruling, the High Court found that the chain of custody had not been satisfactorily demonstrated. Missing cast ballots in certain ballot boxes, including at Namalewe Life Centre, and unexplained changes in the figures undermined confidence in the recount certificate. The court also found failures in the Returning Officer’s statutory safekeeping obligations under section 97(g) of the Parliamentary Elections Act and institutional non-compliance by the Electoral Commission.
The court therefore set aside Mubangizi’s election, declared the seat vacant and ordered a fresh election. It also referred the matter to the Director of Public Prosecutions for investigation. Importantly, a referral for investigation is not a criminal conviction or a finding of individual criminal liability.
No. Uganda had already held the Adjumani West parliamentary by-election on 17 September 2026, following the death of MP General (Rtd) Moses Ali. Buweekula South would therefore be another parliamentary by-election, if the November judgment remains operative and no effective stay prevents implementation. An appeal must also be distinguished from a stay of execution. Filing an appeal does not, by itself, establish that the High Court’s orders have been suspended. Any effective stay must be granted by the competent court.
The Buweekula dispute carries lessons beyond party politics, Electoral materials are the evidential foundation of democratic representation. Ballot papers, declaration forms and recount records must be securely preserved, traceable and independently verifiable. The Electoral Commission’s responsibility does not end when a winner is announced. It extends to safeguarding electoral materials, maintaining accurate records and complying with the law. Equally, the courts must remain independent arbiters, ensuring that neither political influence nor administrative failure determines electoral outcomes. These principles reflect Article 25 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance, both of which affirm the importance of genuine elections and democratic accountability.
For Buweekula South, the immediate priority is a lawful resolution that restores credible representation. Residents cannot indefinitely postpone attention to infrastructure, healthcare, education, agriculture and employment while electoral disputes continue. Ultimately, the central question is not which political camp occupies the parliamentary seat. It is whether the people’s choice can be established through a process that withstands scrutiny.
A democracy does not become stronger because its elections are never challenged. It becomes stronger when disputes are resolved through credible institutions, impartial courts and respect for the rule of law.
